how many mistrials occur and the factors that contribute to them
How Many Mistrials Occur
A mistrial is a legal proceeding that is terminated before a verdict is reached. Mistrials can occur for a variety of reasons, including a hung jury, a procedural error, or the death of a juror.
According to the National Center for State Courts, about 6% of all jury trials in the United States end in hung juries. This means that the jurors are unable to reach a unanimous verdict, either guilty or not guilty. Hung juries are more common in criminal cases than civil cases.
Other reasons for mistrials include
* A juror is unable to continue serving due to illness or other hardship.
* The judge finds that the jury has been exposed to prejudicial information.
* The prosecution or defense makes an error that is so serious that it undermines the fairness of the trial.
Factors That Contribute to Mistrials
There are a number of factors that can contribute to mistrials, including
* The complexity of the case. More complex cases are more likely to result in hung juries, as jurors may have difficulty understanding the evidence or reaching a unanimous decision.
* The strength of the evidence. Cases with weak evidence are more likely to result in mistrials, as jurors may be unable to reach a unanimous verdict on whether the defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
* The skill of the lawyers. Incompetent lawyers can contribute to mistrials by making mistakes that prejudice the jury against their client.
* The behavior of the jurors. Jurors who are biased or disruptive can also contribute to mistrials.
Who Benefits from a Mistrial
A hung jury can benefit both the prosecution and the defense. For the prosecution, a hung jury suggests that the case is not as strong as they had hoped. This can make it more difficult to get a conviction in a retrial. For the defense, a hung jury is a victory, as it means that the defendant has not been convicted.
Conclusion
Mistrials are an unfortunate but sometimes necessary part of the legal system. They can occur for a variety of reasons, and they can benefit both the prosecution and the defense. When a mistrial occurs, the case is usually retried, and the defendant has the opportunity to have their case heard by a new jury.
Here are some additional things to keep in mind about mistrials
* A mistrial does not count as a conviction for the defendant.
* The prosecution can still retry the case, even if there have been multiple mistrials.
* The defendant has the right to a speedy trial, but the prosecution may be able to delay the retrial for strategic reasons.
If you are facing a mistrial, it is important to speak to an experienced criminal defense attorney. They can help you understand your rights and options, and they can represent you in any future proceedings.
0 Comments